Chip vs Chip

MIFARE Classic 4K vs FeliCa Standard

<\/script>\n
'; }, get iframeSnippet() { const domain = '{ SITE_DOMAIN }'; const type = '{ embed_type }'; const slug = '{ embed_slug }'; return ''; }, get activeSnippet() { return this.method === 'script' ? this.scriptSnippet : this.iframeSnippet; }, copySnippet() { navigator.clipboard.writeText(this.activeSnippet).then(() => { this.copied = true; setTimeout(() => { this.copied = false; }, 2000); }); } }" @keydown.escape.window="open = false" @click.outside="open = false">

Embed This Widget

Theme


      
    


    
    

      Widget powered by
      .
      Free, no account required.
    

  




    
    
MIFARE Classic 4K offers 4096 bytes memory with Crypto-1 (broken) security, making it ideal for legacy transit with stored value, multi-application cards. FeliCa Standard provides variable with 3DES mutual authentication security, suited for Japan/HK transit (Suica, Octopus), e-money, ID systems.

    
  


  
  
  

    
      
MIFARE Classic 4K

      

        
FamilyMIFARE

        
Memory4096 bytes (user: 3440 B)

        
Price$0.120 – $0.250

      

    
    
      
FeliCa Standard

      

        
FamilyFeliCa

        
Memory4096 bytes (user: 4096 B)

        
Price$0.500 – $1.500

      

    
  

  

  
  

  






  
  

    
MIFARE Classic 4K vs FeliCa Standard


Both chips were designed for transit and multi-application smart card deployments, but
they emerged from different geographic ecosystems and use different RF command sets.




Overview


MIFARE Classic 4K (NXP): ISO 14443-3A, 4,096 bytes, Crypto-1 (broken), dominant in
European and global legacy transit infrastructure.


FeliCa Standard (Sony): NFC-F (JIS X 6319-4), 212/424 kbps, 3DES authentication/" class="glossary-term-link" data-term="mutual authentication" data-definition="Two-way identity verification between reader and tag" data-category="Security">mutual authentication,
variable memory (~8 KB for Suica), dominant in Japan and Hong Kong transit (Suica, PASMO,
Octopus, iD, nanaco, WAON).




Key Differences


    

  • Speed: FeliCa operates at 212–424 kbps vs Classic 4K's 106 kbps. This enables
  faster gate throughput in high-density transit environments.
    • 

  • Security: Classic 4K's Crypto-1 is fully broken. FeliCa's 3DES provides genuine
  mutual authentication — not as strong as AES-128, but computationally intact.
    • 

  • Geography: Classic 4K is primarily a European and Middle Eastern technology.
  FeliCa is Japan and Hong Kong.
    • 

  • Protocol: Different RF command sets — ISO 14443-A readers cannot read FeliCa and
  vice versa (though modern readers often support both).
    • 

  • Multi-application: Both support multiple applications. FeliCa's file system uses a
  Service Code / Area model; Classic 4K uses sectors.
    • 





Technical Comparison






Parameter
MIFARE Classic 4K
FeliCa Standard






Protocol
ISO 14443-3A
NFC-F




Data rate
106 kbps
212 / 424 kbps




Memory
4,096 bytes
~8 KB (variable)




Security
Crypto-1 (broken)
3DES (intact)




Mutual authentication
Weak
Yes (3DES)




Transit deployments
Europe (legacy)
Japan, Hong Kong




Smartphone emulation
Limited
Yes (Suica on Apple Pay, Google Pay)




Typical cost (volume)
$0.15–$0.35
$0.30–$0.80








Verdict


Geography determines the choice. For Japan/Hong Kong, FeliCa Standard is the required
infrastructure. For European or global deployments, Classic 4K is the legacy option —
but should be migrated to DESFire EV3. Both platforms have better modern successors.

  

  

  
  
  

    
Recommendation

    
Choose MIFARE Classic 4K when you need largest Classic with 4 KB memory; choose FeliCa Standard when you need ultra-fast 212/424 kbps transaction speed.